Explore the concept of the soulmate in some aspect of art or media (such as movies, poetry, or novels). Choosing a narrative from The One, contrast it with one or two examples from other works, showing how they reflect different aspects or perspectives on the theme. (For example, compare Nick’s storyline in The One to the love story in “Brokeback Mountain,” or compare the idea of soulmates in Christopher’s storyline to Heathcliff and Catherine in Wuthering Heights by Emily Brontë.)

Identity is a running theme in Marrs’s work. While the Match technology promises fulfillment, it sometimes destabilizes a character’s sense of self. For example, Amy fights tooth and nail to earn her standing in law enforcement—but she is Matched with a criminal. Similarly, Nick has never considered himself anything but straight—but he is Matched with a man and helplessly feels a profound connection. Discuss the theme of identity in The One. Is there a coherent “message” in the novel?

What do you think of the idea that there is one, and only one, perfect Match for everyone on Earth? What might be the flaws in the argument, or what impact might this belief have on people’s relationship choices? For example, would people postpone dating or marriage in the hope of finding their soulmate? How does your projection compare with the fictional world Marrs presents?